I don’t have life-changing experiences fairly often, now that I’m middle-aged. However a couple of yr in the past, trying to find perception on how conservatism acquired into its present mess, I learn Whittaker Chambers’ Witness for the primary time. Despite its uncommon size, I’m now in the midst of my fifth time studying and listening by means of it, and anticipate to maintain revisiting it. Chambers’ private story and his penetrating political evaluation present a brand new perspective not simply on conservatism however on the entire disaster of polarization and political degeneration.
I learn Witness as a result of Jonah Goldberg included it on a brief record of books that these of us rendered politically homeless by the collapse of conservatism should revisit. I found not solely that Witness is akin to Augustine’s Confessions in its literary magnificence and energy, however that Chambers’ perspective – in Witness and in his letters to William F. Buckley, revealed by Buckley after Chambers’ dying as Odyssey of a Pal – helps clarify why the conservative motion was good and needed, and why it finally turned dysfunctional and proved unsustainable.
Chambers was, famously, discouraged about the way forward for the West. He was so not solely as a result of he had a considerably glum persona (that, too) however as a result of he knew the underlying reason for our political crises was our ethical and religious immaturity. He wrote to Buckley that the longer term appeared bleak to him as a result of the cultural corruption of the West is a political drawback for which there isn’t a political answer. Nonetheless, a full realization of what this implies would go a good distance towards uncovering non-political options – and constructing a politics that welcomes non-political options to our political issues.
The Disaster of Historical past
In his political thought, one in every of Chambers’ organizing ideas is the “disaster of historical past.” The financial and technological improvement of the fashionable world have introduced an finish to older, agrarian methods of life and their traditions. These traditions instructed individuals what the which means and objective of their lives was. Now, we’ve to determine the which means of life for ourselves, and we’ve not developed the mandatory ethical and religious maturity to take action.
That is the true drawback that lies behind all the plain issues of the fashionable world: world wars, tyrannical oppression, alienation, poverty within the midst of lots, and many others. Persons are drawn to totalitarianism – to fascism and communism, and at present we might add spiritual extremism – as a result of they’re pushed to desperation in looking for solutions to those pressing issues. The true reply, that our personal ethical failure is the underlying drawback, is one we by no means wish to settle for. Therefore totalitarianism, which identifies blameable enemies and guarantees to treatment the ills of the fashionable world, is itself one of many ills of the fashionable world, and doubtless all the time will likely be.
Chambers factors out, to our intense discomfort, that the true energy of communism is that it forces to the floor what has all the time been the essential, subterranean query of human life: “God, or Man?” He doesn’t imply the merely philosophical query of whether or not God exists. He means the sensible query of who controls our future.
If we imagine that the future of man is within the palms of man, it follows logically that every one options for human issues should come from the thoughts and energy of man. The human thoughts is in charge of the universe, to the extent that something is. If there are to be options to the catastrophic issues of world conflict, oppression and persevering with poverty in a world of breathtaking progress, the Almighty Thoughts of Man should invent them by itself, after which impose them upon a recalcitrant world.
Such undertakings are typically profitable at first, however are doomed in the long term. The lives and freedoms of some individuals, or just a few million individuals, or perhaps a few hundred million individuals, inevitably pale to insignificance in comparison with the salvation of the entire human race. In the end, if our reply is “Man” somewhat than “God,” we’re going to begin mendacity, dishonest and stealing, and finally torturing and murdering on a mass scale. To commit the crimes of historical past with the intention to ship all future humanity from the crimes of historical past is the best sacrifice the devotee of Man could make to his trigger.
The communist East, Chambers wrote, has chosen “Man” and has the braveness of that conviction. The capitalist West has additionally chosen “Man,” however is haunted by the specter of its Christian previous. That’s the reason the West is in disaster; that’s the reason the world is in disaster.
As Chambers stated, with out God, man can’t manage the world for man. With out God, man can solely manage the world in opposition to man. Some increased energy should restrain us, or else we is not going to be restrained.
On the Proper however Not “Conservative”
Chambers’ witness in opposition to communism, and his withering analysis of the religious vacancy of the American institution that didn’t take the communist risk significantly, isn’t practically as acquainted because it should be. Even conservatives have largely forgotten Witness at this level, regardless that the merciless and shameful mistreatment of Chambers by the hands of the American institution was one of many key origin tales of the motion. However Chambers’ critique of conservatism itself isn’t simply uncared for; it by no means actually turned well-known within the first place.
Buckley sought out Chambers after studying in Witness the story of how Chambers abandoned his job as a spy for the Soviet Union due to his spiritual conversion. The 2 turned shut associates, and Chambers briefly wrote for Nationwide Evaluate. Amongst his articles was a deconstruction of Ayn Rand that is still to today one of many key paperwork of American mental life.
However Chambers all the time insisted that whereas he was a person of the Proper, he was not “conservative.” His letters explaining his resignation from Nationwide Evaluate comprise one of the crucial incisive mental critiques of American conservatism ever written. (Buckley confirmed admirable pluck in selecting to publish them!)
Chambers’ encounter with the conservatives had pressured him to make a key concession. In Witness, and certainly for his entire grownup life, Chambers’ response to the disaster of historical past was to retreat to agrarian traditionalism. After leaving the Soviet underground, the Chambers household lived on a household farm that they labored fully by themselves, on prime of Chambers’ more-than-a-full-time job at Time journal (the place he rose to senior editor). However Buckley and the conservatives pressured Chambers to acknowledge that human freedom – his core political concern – required openness to technological and financial improvement.
Chambers wrote to Buckley: “I’ve determined that the machine isn’t the enemy.” And this concession, which the conservatives had pressured him to make, turned the place to begin of his critique of conservatism.
The entire conservative challenge, Chambers confirmed, rested on the belief that our society’s outdated, conventional ethical and non secular construction would proceed unchanged by default, so long as overweening Massive Authorities stayed out of the best way. However the technological and financial improvement welcomed by financial conservatism should completely destabilize the establishments that undergird the ethical norms and non secular sensibilities demanded by social conservatism. What’s primarily wanted to satisfy the disaster of historical past isn’t the mere conservation of outdated ethical and non secular establishments, however a continuous reform and redesign of these establishments. Not a continuous reform within the useless pursuit of progress on human phrases, however a continuous reform to manifest the justice and mercy of the everlasting and transcendent God in a world being continually remade by technological and financial improvement.
The thought of a doubtlessly deadly rigidity between financial liberalism and social conservatism is, in fact, a well-recognized line of assault on conservatism. What makes Chambers’ model a lot extra incisive is that it lays apart the secondary points and cuts to the guts of the difficulty: the connection between God and social establishments. If our dedication to God and his holy love for an unholy human race is to stay unchanged, then our ethical and non secular establishments should change continually.
One of many clearest indicators of a refined thoughts is the flexibility to differentiate issues with out separating them. Chambers neither identifies God with ethical and non secular establishments, as social conservatives are likely to do; nor tries to have God with out ethical and non secular establishments, as sure liberal, modernizing spiritual individuals attempt to do; nor tries to have morality with out God, as secularists (together with secular conservatives) attempt vainly to do. We will need to have each God and establishments, but they don’t seem to be the identical factor, and it requires fixed battle and fixed reform to maintain them aligned.
Conservatives are proper to insist on particular person rights and free markets, and the success of the motion within the 20th century was an excellent and needed restraint on what would in any other case have been the unrestrained progress of state energy. However this isn’t sufficient. To suppose that limiting authorities would, by itself, be ample to satisfy the disaster of historical past smacks strongly of that imaginative and prescient of the Almighty Thoughts of Man, planning its personal salvation. As if society might clear up all its issues if we might simply get our public coverage proper – fine-tuning the legal guidelines defending particular person rights and free markets till they’re so good that nobody will have to be good.
Cash and Energy Can’t Save Us
In our polarized second, I believe Chambers’ story and thought might assist each the Left and Proper flip away from the idolatry of energy and materialism that’s destroying us.
For my associates on the Left, an encounter with Chambers – a person who shared all their considerations about peace, justice for the poor and resistance to white supremacy, and bore a costlier private witness to all these causes than nearly any of them ever will – would assist reveal what was good and needed within the conservative motion. It could, I hope, compel a reckoning with the persistent tendency of the Left’s public representatives to glamorize and romanticize mass murderers (Che Guevara, the Castros, and even typically North Korea). It might assist them acknowledge the large extent to which the ability of the American institution has been used to mistreat individuals on the Proper for nearly a century. Most significantly, it could problem them to confront the phantasm that society can clear up its issues by giving energy to authorities bureaucracies and politicized pseudo-experts.
However I, as a person of the Proper, have additionally been troubled by my encounter with Chambers – a person who shared all our considerations about particular person rights and free markets, and bore a costlier private witness to those causes than nearly any of us ever will. In comparison with the progressivism of the New Deal and the Nice Society, the Left at present appears a lot much less beholden to a grand cosmic imaginative and prescient of the Almighty Thoughts of Man, planning its personal salvation. But we too usually discuss our progressive neighbors as if anybody who favors a welfare state even barely bigger than what we’re keen to countenance is only one step away from totalitarianism and mass homicide. And the powerlessness of Chambers earlier than the lies and abuses of the American institution contrasts starkly with the large engines of cash and energy which have been constructed up on the Proper for the reason that 1980s. Too many on the Proper have change into the very oppressors that Chambers and Buckley got down to combat. Too many follow the identical politics of grievance, resentment, and sufferer tradition that we accuse the Left of working towards.
As I closed my copy of Odyssey of a Pal, simply after studying these hanging letters of resignation from Nationwide Evaluate close to the top of his life, two issues struck me. One was that it’s a testimony to divine inscrutability that nice thinkers are so usually taken from us simply as they’re making new discoveries whose implications they are going to by no means have the possibility to discover. The opposite was that, for all its devotion to some particular ethical causes and its championing of the social utility of faith and non secular establishments, the underlying failure of the conservative motion was severe return to ethical accountability – which finally means individuals changing into humble and obedient earlier than the face of the cosmic energy that transcends them – was not central sufficient to the conservative challenge, and couldn’t have been made so with out basically altering the character of the challenge.
(function(d, s, id) (document, “script”, “facebook-jssdk”));